Skip to content

When Convenience Becomes Surveillance

Okay, you got your cell phone, your PC, tablet, your Wi-Fi, your smart TV, and your connected car with GPS. What does that say about you? More than you probably know.

Line graph from Pew Research showing trends in smart and other cell phone ownership, 2000 - 2026
Rates of smart and other cell phone ownership, US, 2000 – 2026 (Pew Research survey    ). 98% of US adults own a cell phone and 91% have a smart phone. Click to see report.

Read Online

Firstly, it’s premature to comment on recent IT outages, except to say that when Air Traffic Control’s comms, Microsoft’s cloud apps, Apple Pay, Chase Bank, and various websites go down in short order, there must be root causes that aren’t being discussed. So while waiting for the dust to clear, let’s talk about why information technology, after putting us in its thrall, now threatens our security, privacy, and personal assets.

As are listed here, Perfidy Press Provocations has been describing threats posed by information technologies and their perpetrators since 2021. But even before then, I was describing how big tech has victimized as much as it has empowered us, starting with a 1999 polemic about “innovation” called Vain Notion (an anagram). I moonlighted it when writing a newsletter for an IT research firm west of Boston called IDC. My job there was to shill for the computer industry, boiling down analyst’s forecasts of adoption of PCs, cell phones, storage devices, networks, and other IT goodies in a weekly newsletter to over 60,000 subscribers. Before that I was a software developer and afterward a tech writer.

That’s to say I’ve been doing and following IT for a long time. And year after year I’ve seen it progressively sap social and individual well-being. Physically, we sit too much and get repetitive motion ailments. Our virtual selves are not doing well either. Online we are surveilled, profiled, tempted, phished, scammed, and hacked, more often every day it seems.

Social and personal problems multiplied after we were herded onto the Internet and then cell phones, starting in the 90s. We were hooked by peer pressure and seduced by frictionless convenience only to be pestered by scam artists, bullied by peers, and monetized by the rent-seekers who beat paths to our browsers and inboxes, not to mention by hackers running up bills on our credit cards and draining our bank accounts by filching our credentials, so now we must use two-factor authentication and change passwords regularly. Who needed this?

And it’s expensive. Since the eclipse of landlines running over copper wires to phones that consumed no power, we’ve been forced to to acquire new gadgets. Home phone service now requires fiber or cable interfaces and everyone who’s anybody needs a router, all of which raise your telecom bills. So you ditch the land line and rely on your cell phone, for which you can spend a kilobuck or more to get locked into a carrier that keeps jacking up its fees. Add to that the planned obsolescence, a steady stream of upgrades that eventually brick your device maybe even before you finish paying for it.

Did I mention the surveillance features? Since cell carriers need to know where you are to provide service you are continually tracked wherever you go. Then there are the apps that want to use our location, provided mostly by GPS chips in our phones. Stores use them to push deals at you when they spot your phone in their vicinity. TV’s listen in on our living room conversations. Auto companies bug our cars and sell the data to insurance companies that monitor our driving habits to adjust our premiums.There’s no escape except by taking countermeasure that cost time, cancel contracts, and cause inconvenience.

As if automakers tracking you weren’t enough, that friendly GPS lady guiding you to your destination also whispers your itinerary to parts unknown. And hundreds of local authorities now deploy automatic license plate readers (ALPRs) to note your whereabouts, broadcasting it over data networks span the continent and are frequently abused by bored cops stalking people on a personal whim, with minimal safeguards and few repercussions.* The Electronic Frontiers Foundation (EFF) has a nice rundown of them here. Many people object to their presence and a number or cameras have been sabotaged. Citizen opposition has led to more than 500 localities cancelling their ALPR contracts with vendors. Might yours be one of them?

Massachusetts Fusion Center, Google street view
Massachusetts Fusion Center, Google street view

ALPR data easily finds its way to data “fusion centers,“ 79 of them across America under the aegis of the National Counterterrorism Center. Their job it is to coordinate crime and signals intelligence (SIGINT) data from local and national sources, including raw data from the NSA. This is Massachusetts’ fusion center, which happens to be located in my town. It resembles a prison. Here’s a glimpse into what this looks like nationwide.

Map from Electronic Frontiers Fdtn of law enforcement fusion and real-time crime centers in the lower 48 states.
The 79 law enforcement fusion centers (blue) and 240 real-time crime centers (orange) in the lower 48 US states. From the Electronic Frontiers Foundation Atlas of Surveillance.

Lastly, it may surprise you that ICE has contracted AT&T to provide call records in bulk. You would think requesting call records must done on a case-by-case basis under FISA warrants, but you would be wrong. ICE hoovers up the data to it’s black heart’s content. 404 Media reports:

Another document previously obtained by Senator Wyden’s office [indicates that AT&T’s] services include linking multiple devices or phone numbers to an identified target; identifying devices that have had their SIM cards replaced; determining whether phones associated with an international investigation target have entered the U.S.; and deconflicting international phone numbers associated with targets. That document was provided by the Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP), an obscure White House-affiliated entity that previously funded the Hemisphere program, and which 404 Media reported is behind a growing nationwide network of automatic license plate readers (ALPRs). According to documents previously obtained by the EFF and EPIC, the AT&T program contains more than a trillion phone records.

And short of lawsuits, there’s nothing anybody outside the Trump Administration can do to stop it. 

If you want to find out who is keeping tabs on you by what means, a good place to start is EFF’s Atlas of Surveillance. Its database itemizes and its site maps surveillance technologies employed by particular jurisdictions across the US. Give it your city, town, or ZIP to search.

This map shows all the data layers from the atlas in my region. White dots show police departments using body cameras. Yellow dots are ALPRs. Grey dots represent commercial applications used to collect, analyze, distribute and combine various forms of surveillance data. A state-wide agreement in Massachusetts gives local police department access to data from 11 gunshot detectors across the state. The Cities of Boston, New York, and Albany have cell site simulators, plus Framingham MA.

Data layers in the EFF Atlas of Surveillance for southern New England

EFF acknowledges that its data is incomplete and welcomes contributions to its database. You can forward information or volunteer to research surveillance in your locality.

Who okayed all this?


* Check Have I Been Flocked to see if your car’s license plate has been searched in Flock.


Visit Perfidy Press Bookstore

You can find this and previous Perfidy Press Provocations in our newsletter archive. Should you see any you like, please consider forwarding this or links to others to people who might like to subscribe, and thanks.

Visit Perfidy Press
Published inEssayNewsletternonfictionPrivacyTechnology

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.